Posted: Thu 19th Jan 2017

Deeside based MoneySuperMarket takes top spot in most complained about adverts on TV in 2016

News and Info from Deeside, Flintshire, North Wales
This article is old - Published: Thursday, Jan 19th, 2017


Campaign Advert

Deeside-based MoneySuperMarket has come out top again when it comes to most complained about adverts on TV.

The Ewloe headquartered business had three adverts, Gary the dancing bodyguard, twerking businessman Dave and builder Colin make the Advertising Standards Agency (ASA) top ten list of most complained about adverts of 2016.

ASA the advertising watchdog said three MoneySuperMarket ads, none of which were banned, received a total of 2,491 complaints from offended viewers.

Top of the pile with 1,063 complaints featured Gary the bodyguard dressed in a suit and sunglasses, dancing at a rally.

Viewers mainly complained that Gary’s moves were overtly sexual and not suitable to be seen by children.

The ASA judged that the ad would not cause serious or widespread offence to viewers and was generally likely to be interpreted in a humorous manner.

Second with 898 complaints came MoneySuperMarket’s ‘Epic Squads’ TV ad showing Dave, dressed in a suit jacket, denim shorts and high heels, and another character Colin, dressed in a fluorescent jacket and hard hat, engaged in a gang dance-off.

Viewers said the ad was offensive and overtly sexual, while some people objected that it could be seen to be homophobic and could encourage hate crimes.

The ASA concluded that it was unlikely to provoke serious or widespread offence or to be seen as condoning or encouraging harmful discriminatory behaviour in real life.

A third MoneySuperMarket ad drew 530 complaints, featuring Dave and Colin who alone in an underground car park, each performed dance moves in a bid to out-do each other.

Viewers complained that it was overtly sexual and offensive because it showed what they perceived to be two homosexuals together.

The ASA ruled the ad did not break the rules as the majority of viewers would interpret the scenes as light-hearted and humorous.

Most complained about in 2015

Moneysupermarket also topped the list in 2015 with its now legendary advert featuring Dave who was seen strutting down a street in hotpants and high heels.

The ASA found that none of the ads in the 2016 top 10 list “crossed the line” between bad taste and offence.

ASA chief executive Guy Parker said:

The ads that attract the highest number of complaints are often not the ones that need banning. Our action leads to thousands of ads being amended or withdrawn each year, mostly for being misleading, but there wasn’t one misleading ad in the top 10.

In the list there are a number of ads, which while advertising their product or service, have also sought to present a positive statement about diversity but were in fact seen by some as doing the opposite.

In all those cases, we thought people generally would see the ads in a positive light and that the boundary between bad taste and serious or widespread offence had been navigated well enough, often through using sensible scheduling restrictions.

The 10 most complained-about ads of 2016 are:

1. MoneySuperMarket.com. 1,063 complaints. Not upheld.
This TV ad featured Gary the bodyguard dressed in a suit and sunglasses, dancing at a rally. Viewers mainly complained that Gary’s moves were overtly sexual and not suitable to be seen by children. The ASA judged that the ad would not cause serious or widespread offence to viewers and was generally likely to be interpreted in a humorous manner.

2. MoneySuperMarket.com. 898 complaints. Not upheld.
MoneySuperMarket’s ‘Epic Squads’ TV ad showed Dave, dressed in a suit jacket, denim shorts and high heels, and another character Colin, dressed in a fluorescent jacket and hard hat, engaged in a gang dance-off. Viewers said the ad was offensive and overtly sexual, while some people objected that it could be seen to be homophobic and could encourage hate crimes.
The ASA concluded that it was unlikely to provoke serious or widespread offence or to be seen as condoning or encouraging harmful discriminatory behaviour in real life.

3. Match.com. 896 complaints. Not upheld
This TV ad showed a women getting home from work to her female partner who removed her top and passionately kissed her. Complainants challenged whether the ad was sexually explicit and inappropriately scheduled.
The ASA judged that the ad would not cause serious or widespread offence and were satisfied that the scheduling restriction prevented it being shown in or around dedicated children’s programmes or those with particular appeal to children.

4. MoneySuperMarket.com. 530 complaints. Not upheld.
Another TV ad featuring Dave and Colin. This time they were alone in an underground car park and each performed dance moves in a bid to out-do each other. Viewers complained that it was overtly sexual and offensive because it showed what they perceived to be two homosexuals together.
The ASA ruled the ad did not break the rules as the majority of viewers would interpret the scenes as light-hearted and humorous.

5. Paddy Power. 450 complaints. Not upheld.
A re-run of the 2010 ad featured two teams of blindfolded men playing football. Viewers once again objected to the scene where it was suggested a man had kicked a cat that had run on to the pitch after mistaking it for the ball.
The ASA originally concluded that the majority of viewers would see the ad as humorous and not humiliating or undermining to blind people and did not reinvestigate.

6. Smart Energy GB. 253 complaints. Not upheld.
Smart Energy’s ad showed cartoon characters Gaz and Leccy being burnt in a toaster and hit across the room with a spatula, being cooked in a microwave and electrocuted by the television set. Viewers complained that it was excessively violent.
The ASA was the ad was clearly surreal and fantastical.

7. Paddy Power. 220 complaints. Not upheld
This ad showed a group of Scottish people singing about not qualifying for UEFA Euro 2016 but not minding because they could still bet on England to lose. Viewers said it was racist and encouraged anti-English views.
The ASA ruled the stereotypical features used to describe and depict the Scottish people in the ad would largely be understood to be a celebration of Scottish culture rather than malicious mocking.

8. Home Office. 216 complaints. Not upheld
The ad featured various scenarios which were unacceptable in a relationship and prompted complaints that it was sexist and irresponsible. Viewers complained that it implied only men engaged in abusive behaviours and that the ad might actually prevent male victims of domestic abuse from seeking help.

9. Gourmet Burger Kitchen. 195 complaints. Not upheld.
Complainants believed the ad was offensive to vegetarians and vegans with wording such as: “You’ll always remember when you gave up being a vegetarian” and “Anyone fancy a nice, juicy, 6oz lettuce?”
The restaurant took independent action to withdraw three of the ads.

10. Mars/Maltesers. 151 complaints. Not upheld.
The ad showed a woman in a wheelchair discussing her new boyfriend with two of her friends while enjoying Maltesers. She mentioned how her disability caused her to have a spasm during a romantic encounter, which her boyfriend ‘misinterpreted’. Viewers said the ad was overtly sexual and offensive to disabled people.
The ASA said the post-9pm restriction prevented children from seeing it and it was likely to be seen as championing diversity and disability, not ridiculing it.s.”

 

Spotted something? Got a story? Send a Facebook Message | A direct message on Twitter | Email: [email protected]
Latest News

  • Flintshire councillor accused of abusing power to get sandbags for family during flooding
  • Flintshire Council committee set to consider if rule prohibiting Councillors from ‘seeking sexual favours’ is required
  • Olympic Games: Flint High School cheers on Jade Jones for Paris 2024

  • More...

    Flintshire councillor accused of abusing power to get sandbags for family during flooding

    News

    Flintshire Council committee set to consider if rule prohibiting Councillors from ‘seeking sexual favours’ is required

    News

    Olympic Games: Flint High School cheers on Jade Jones for Paris 2024

    News

    Bailey Hill: Step back in time at Mold’s Medieval Day

    News

    Mancot burst water main expected to be fixed by 2pm, says Welsh Water

    News

    M56 resurfacing near Manchester Airport to start on June 10

    News

    Shotton property conversion to 5-bedroom HMO proposed

    News

    Food inflation returns to ‘normal levels’

    News

    Julian shines in first race for Deestriders

    News